Spirituality · Benedictine

INTRODUCTION TO BENEDICTINE SPIRITUALITY

Seeking God Through Prayer, Work, Stability, Humility, Community, and Daily Conversion

Benedictine Spirituality

Essential Catholic Synthesis

Benedictine spirituality is a Catholic way of seeking God shaped by the Rule of St. Benedict of Nursia. It orders the whole of life toward Christ through the sacred liturgy, prayerful reading of Scripture, faithful work, stability, obedience, humility, silence, hospitality, community, and daily conversion.

The Holy Rule was written for monks living a common life under an abbot. Its first and fullest home therefore remains the monastery. Yet its wisdom has long nourished the wider Church. Clergy, religious, oblates, married people, families, workers, students, and other lay Catholics can receive its principles when they adapt them honestly to their actual vocation rather than pretending to live a monastic life they have not received.

Benedictine spirituality does not seek God by fleeing from ordinary reality. It allows ordinary actions to become places of obedience, offering, and charity. Prayer gives order to work. Silence makes listening possible. Stability allows grace to work over time. Community reveals the need for patience and forgiveness. Hospitality receives Christ in the guest. Humility opens the heart to truth.

The Benedictine way is neither passive nor severe for its own sake. It is a balanced school of Gospel discipleship. Its purpose is that the Christian may prefer nothing to Christ and, through perseverance, come to the perfect love that casts out fear.

Key Truths

  • Benedictine spirituality is rooted in the Gospel and given stable form by the Rule of St. Benedict.
  • Its central purpose is to seek God and prefer nothing whatever to Christ.
  • The Holy Eucharist and the sacred liturgy stand at the heart of Benedictine life.
  • The Divine Office sanctifies time through the Psalms and the prayer of the Church.
  • Lectio divina receives Sacred Scripture through attentive reading, meditation, prayer, contemplation, and faithful action.
  • Prayer and work belong within one life ordered toward God.
  • Stability creates the rootedness in which perseverance, truth, and charity can mature.
  • Conversatio morum signifies fidelity to the monastic manner of life and continuing conversion.
  • Obedience begins with listening and is directed toward Christ, not arbitrary human control.
  • Humility means living truthfully before God in dependence upon grace.
  • Silence disciplines speech and creates space for prayer, attention, and charity.
  • Guests, the sick, the elderly, the weak, and every member of the community are to be served with reverence.
  • Benedictine moderation orders food, sleep, work, prayer, possessions, discipline, and community life toward holiness.
  • The Rule is first a monastic rule; lay application must respect marriage, family, work, health, parish life, and other duties.
  • The surest fruits of Benedictine spirituality are fidelity, peace, humility, hospitality, perseverance, and love of Christ.

In This Article

What Benedictine Spirituality Is

Benedictine spirituality is the spiritual patrimony that has developed around the life, Rule, and monastic descendants of St. Benedict of Nursia. It is one of the most enduring schools of spirituality in the Latin Church and has profoundly influenced Christian worship, prayer, education, culture, hospitality, missionary life, and the preservation of learning.

Its deepest meaning, however, is not historical influence. Benedictine spirituality is a way of following Jesus Christ. It seeks to order the whole person and the whole day toward God.

The Rule includes guidance about prayer, authority, counsel, discipline, possessions, meals, sleep, work, guests, the sick, the elderly, travel, and the reception of new members. This breadth reveals a central Benedictine conviction: no ordinary part of life lies outside the call to holiness.

The tradition is practical without being merely pragmatic. Its practices serve contemplation and charity. Work, silence, restraint, obedience, and community are not ends in themselves. They form a person who can listen to God and love with increasing freedom.

Benedictine spirituality may therefore be summarized as a stable, liturgical, scriptural, communal, ascetical, and Christ-centered path of daily conversion.

Seeking God

The fundamental Benedictine question is whether a person truly seeks God. The Rule asks that this desire be tested in one who seeks entrance into the monastery.

To seek God is more than to possess religious interests or enjoy sacred beauty. It means directing the intellect, will, affections, body, time, work, relationships, and possessions toward communion with Him.

The search begins because God has first sought and called the person. The monk does not discover an absent God by personal achievement. He responds to the God who speaks through Scripture, Christ, the Church, the sacraments, the abbot, the brethren, the poor, and the events of providence.

“Seek ye the Lord, and be strengthened: seek his face evermore.”

Psalm 33:11 — Douay-Rheims Bible

Seeking God requires perseverance. The person may experience consolation, dryness, peace, restlessness, clarity, temptation, or fatigue. The search cannot depend upon a preferred feeling.

Benedictine stability protects this search from becoming a pursuit of endless novelty. God is sought here, today, in the next prayer, the next task, the next act of charity, and the next opportunity to obey.

The Rule as a School of Discipleship

St. Benedict describes the monastery as a school of the Lord’s service. The image is important. A school forms through teaching, repetition, correction, practice, patience, and growth.

The Rule is not a collection of abstract ideals. It gives a concrete pattern through which the Gospel is practiced in community. The monk does not choose only the instructions that match his temperament. He receives a common way of life.

The Rule is marked by sobriety and discretion. St. Benedict adapts discipline to weakness, age, health, circumstances, and capacity. He expects effort but warns against arrangements that crush the weak or discourage beginners.

This moderation does not make the Rule lax. It asks for renunciation of self-will, obedience, common ownership, disciplined speech, perseverance, and continuing conversion.

The Rule is not equal to Sacred Scripture or the Church’s universal law. It is an ecclesially received monastic rule ordered beneath the Gospel, the liturgy, and the authority of the Church.

“We intend to establish a school for the Lord’s service.”

Rule of St. Benedict, Prologue

Christ at the Center

The Benedictine life is radically Christ-centered. Christ is encountered in the sacred liturgy, Sacred Scripture, the abbot, the sick, the guest, the poor, and the brethren.

The Rule repeatedly directs the monk away from self-will toward the service of Christ. Its final chapter on good zeal commands that nothing whatever be preferred to Christ.

This Christ-centeredness prevents Benedictine spirituality from becoming a technique for calm, productivity, or personal balance. Peace and order are genuine fruits, but the goal is communion with Jesus.

Christ is also the model of obedience, humility, service, and patient suffering. The monk follows Him not only in the beauty of chant and prayer, but also in correction, hidden labor, difficult relationships, illness, and perseverance.

“Let them prefer nothing whatever to Christ.”

Rule of St. Benedict, chapter 72

Every Benedictine practice must be judged by this center. Does it lead to Christ, conformity with Christ, and love of those who belong to Christ?

The Sacred Liturgy and the Work of God

The sacred liturgy gives Benedictine life its deepest rhythm. The Holy Eucharist is the source and summit of Christian life, and the Divine Office extends the praise of the Church through the hours of the day.

St. Benedict calls the Divine Office the Work of God. He directs that nothing be preferred to it. This does not mean that liturgical prayer is the only duty in the monastery. It means that worship establishes the order within which all other duties receive their proper place.

The Psalms train the whole person to pray. They contain praise, thanksgiving, lament, repentance, confidence, fear, suffering, judgment, longing, and hope. By returning to them daily, the monk learns to bring every condition of the heart before God.

Liturgical prayer is ecclesial. The monk does not pray merely as a private individual. He joins the prayer of Christ and His Body and carries before God the needs of the Church and the world.

Lay Catholics can receive this Benedictine love for liturgical prayer through faithful Mass attendance and prudent use of Morning Prayer, Evening Prayer, Night Prayer, or other parts of the Liturgy of the Hours.

Lectio Divina

Lectio divina is prayerful sacred reading. It approaches Scripture not merely as information to master, but as the word of God to be heard, received, prayed, and obeyed.

A traditional description includes:

  • Lectio: reading the text attentively.
  • Meditatio: considering its meaning and allowing it to question the heart.
  • Oratio: responding to God in prayer.
  • Contemplatio: resting in loving attention to God.
  • Actio: carrying the word into faithful action.

These movements are not a rigid technique. They often overlap. The purpose is communion and conversion.

Benedictine reading is slow enough for attention. It resists the modern habit of consuming many words without receiving them.

Lectio divina should remain within the faith of the Church. Private impressions do not overrule Catholic doctrine, moral truth, or the proper interpretation of Scripture.

A practical beginning is to pray slowly with the Gospel for the coming Sunday, noting one word, command, promise, or mystery that should shape the week.

Ora et Labora

Benedictine spirituality is often summarized by the Latin phrase ora et labora: pray and work. The exact phrase is not a line from the Rule, but it expresses the Benedictine integration of worship and labor.

Prayer and work are not competitors. Prayer orders work toward God. Work gives concrete expression to obedience, stewardship, service, and charity.

Work in the Benedictine spirit is not worship of productivity. The Rule also protects time for prayer, sacred reading, meals, rest, and care of the weak.

Honest labor can:

  • Serve the community
  • Support the monastery or household
  • Discipline attention
  • Develop competence
  • Provide goods for others
  • Become an offering to God
  • Reveal impatience, pride, or avoidance

For lay Catholics, ora et labora means performing employment, household duties, caregiving, study, and service in the presence of God. It does not mean praying constantly in a way that prevents careful attention to the task.

A brief offering before work and a prayer of thanksgiving afterward can help unite action to God.

Stability

Stability is one of the distinctive promises of Benedictine monastic profession. The monk binds himself to a particular monastic community rather than treating the monastery as a temporary spiritual service.

Stability creates the place where love must become concrete. It is easier to admire community in theory than to live patiently with the same imperfect people over many years.

Stability opposes restless escape, but it does not mean that every external circumstance can never change. Nor does it require a person to remain in abuse or danger. Its essence is faithful rootedness within a received vocation and community.

For lay Catholics, stability is not a monastic vow. Its wisdom can be lived through fidelity to marriage, children, parish, work, prayer, place, and legitimate commitments.

Stability asks:

  • Am I always imagining holiness somewhere else?
  • Do I abandon good practices when they become ordinary?
  • Do I leave relationships rather than practice forgiveness and truth?
  • Can I remain faithful while legitimate change unfolds?

Stability gives grace time to uncover deeper motives and form durable charity.

Conversion of Life

The Benedictine profession includes the promise commonly expressed as conversatio morum. Its translation has been discussed in different ways, but it refers to fidelity to the monastic manner of life and therefore includes continuing conversion.

It should not be reduced to a vague promise to become a better person. Within the monastery it embraces the actual disciplines and renunciations of monastic life.

Conversion is daily because self-will, pride, distraction, resentment, and disordered desire return daily.

Benedictine conversion includes:

  • Turning from sin
  • Receiving correction
  • Renewing prayer
  • Practicing chastity according to vocation
  • Using goods without possessiveness
  • Serving the community
  • Persevering through dryness
  • Beginning again after failure

Lay Catholics do not make the monastic promise simply by adopting Benedictine practices. They can nevertheless receive its call to a life that is continually reformed by the Gospel.

Obedience and Listening

The Rule begins with the call to listen with the ear of the heart. In Benedictine spirituality, obedience grows from this attentive listening.

The monk listens to God through Scripture, the Rule, the sacred liturgy, the abbot, the needs of the community, and the concrete demands of charity.

Obedience is modeled upon Christ, who became obedient unto death. It is not mere external compliance but the offering of self-will to God.

At the same time, Benedictine obedience is not arbitrary domination. The abbot is accountable to God, must seek counsel, adapt burdens to persons, and remember that he serves souls.

No legitimate obedience can require sin. Spiritual authority must remain within its proper scope and the law of the Church.

For lay Catholics, obedience includes fidelity to God, Catholic teaching, legitimate Church authority, just civil authority, marriage promises, contracts, duties, and the demands of truth.

“He humbled himself, becoming obedient unto death, even to the death of the cross.”

Philippians 2:8 — Douay-Rheims Bible

Humility

Chapter seven of the Rule presents a long teaching on humility. Benedictine humility is not self-hatred, denial of gifts, or passive submission to mistreatment.

Humility is truth before God. The person recognizes that he is a creature, sinner, recipient of grace, member of a community, and servant of Christ.

Humility appears through:

  • Fear of offending God
  • Renunciation of self-will
  • Obedience
  • Patience under difficulty
  • Honest disclosure
  • Contentment with ordinary place
  • Restraint in speech
  • Freedom from self-exaltation

The goal of the steps of humility is perfect charity. What was once performed through fear becomes increasingly natural through love and holy habit.

Humility therefore does not destroy confidence. It transfers confidence from self-sufficiency to grace.

Silence and Recollection

Benedictine silence protects listening, prayer, peace, and community. It is not absolute muteness and not avoidance of necessary conversation.

The Rule particularly warns against excessive, foolish, harmful, and idle speech. Speech can wound charity, spread gossip, excite anger, or feed pride.

Silence disciplines the need to react immediately. It creates room to hear Scripture, notice another person, examine motives, and choose words wisely.

Modern life makes this discipline especially valuable. Constant audio, messaging, video, alerts, and commentary can leave the heart unable to attend.

A lay Benedictine practice of silence might include:

  • No phone during morning prayer
  • A quiet period before Mass
  • Silence during part of a commute
  • Restraint from gossip
  • A nightly period without media
  • Pausing before responding in conflict

Silence is fruitful when it leads to more truthful speech and more attentive love.

Community and Charity

The Rule is written principally for cenobites: monks living in a monastery under a rule and an abbot. Benedictine spirituality is therefore fundamentally communal.

Community is not merely a source of companionship. It is a school of charity in which preferences, weaknesses, conflicts, gifts, and needs are brought into common life.

The strong are asked to be patient with the weak. The weak are not to be crushed. The sick receive special care. The elderly and children are treated with consideration. Decisions involve counsel.

Good zeal, described near the conclusion of the Rule, includes mutual respect, patient endurance of weakness, obedience offered to one another, and selfless concern for the good of the other.

Community corrects spiritual individualism. A person cannot claim deep love of God while habitually despising those with whom he lives.

For lay Catholics, the first community of charity may be marriage and family. Benedictine principles should make the home more patient, prayerful, orderly, and hospitable—not turn one family member into a self-appointed abbot over the others.

Hospitality

The Rule commands that all guests be received as Christ. This is among its best-known teachings.

Hospitality includes reverence, welcome, prayer, food, attention, and care. It is especially attentive to the poor and pilgrims, in whom Christ is received in a particular way.

“Let all guests who arrive be received as Christ.”

Rule of St. Benedict, chapter 53

Benedictine hospitality is not entertainment, display, or the removal of every boundary. A monastery has an order that protects prayer and community even while receiving guests generously.

For lay Catholics, hospitality may include:

  • Welcoming someone into the home
  • Listening without rushing
  • Serving a meal
  • Making room for the lonely
  • Receiving interruptions with patience
  • Supporting travelers, refugees, or those in need
  • Treating service workers and strangers with dignity

Hospitality sees the person before the inconvenience.

Moderation, Stewardship, and Peace

The Rule is often admired for balance. The more precise Benedictine virtue is discretion: wise judgment that adapts discipline without abandoning the goal.

St. Benedict considers age, sickness, climate, work, weakness, and local conditions. He seeks an order in which the strong have something to strive for and the weak are not driven away.

Moderation concerns:

  • Food and drink
  • Sleep
  • Work
  • Prayer
  • Speech
  • Discipline
  • Possessions
  • Leadership

Stewardship also receives careful attention. Tools and goods of the monastery are to be treated responsibly. Possessions serve common life, not private accumulation.

Peace is the fruit of right order, justice, forgiveness, worship, and charity. It is not merely an atmosphere or design preference.

Benedictine Spirituality for Lay Catholics

The Rule was written for monks. Respect for that fact protects lay application from fantasy and appropriation.

Lay Catholics may receive Benedictine wisdom through:

  • Faithful Sunday Mass
  • Parts of the Liturgy of the Hours
  • Lectio divina
  • A stable daily prayer schedule
  • Prayerful work
  • Moderation and simplicity
  • Hospitality
  • Fidelity to place and vocation
  • Care for the sick and elderly
  • Intentional silence

Benedictine oblates have a formal spiritual affiliation with a monastery while remaining in their secular or clerical state. They receive formation and seek to live the spirit of the Rule according to their circumstances.

Not every person drawn to Benedictine spirituality is called to become an oblate. Informal learning can also bear fruit.

Family duties ordinarily take priority over optional monastic-inspired practices. A parent should not neglect children in order to reproduce a full monastic Office. A worker should not use silence to avoid necessary communication.

The authentic question is not, “How can I imitate the monastery externally?” but, “How can Benedictine wisdom make me more faithful to the vocation God has actually given?”

Why the Benedictine Way Matters Today

Modern life often rewards speed, interruption, novelty, mobility, self-promotion, consumption, and constant availability.

Benedictine spirituality offers a different formation:

  • Listening instead of constant reaction
  • Stability instead of restless escape
  • Liturgical time instead of endless urgency
  • Sacred reading instead of information consumption
  • Community instead of isolated self-definition
  • Hospitality instead of inconvenience avoidance
  • Moderation instead of excess
  • Hidden fidelity instead of spiritual performance

This contrast should not become romantic rejection of technology, cities, mobility, or modern work. Benedictine wisdom teaches that tools and circumstances must be ordered toward human and supernatural goods.

Its relevance comes from its realism about the human person. We need rhythm, worship, limits, correction, community, work, rest, forgiveness, and perseverance.

The Benedictine way reminds the Church that holiness is ordinarily formed through faithful days rather than dramatic moments.

Common Misunderstandings

“Benedictine spirituality is only for monks.”

The Rule is first for monks, but its principles can nourish clergy, religious, oblates, families, and other lay Catholics when adapted responsibly.

“The phrase Ora et Labora appears in the Rule.”

The phrase fittingly summarizes Benedictine integration, but it is not an exact quotation from the Holy Rule.

“Stability means never changing anything.”

Stability means faithful rootedness. It does not forbid prudent change or require remaining in danger or abuse.

“Humility means thinking badly of yourself.”

Humility means living truthfully before God, acknowledging gifts and weaknesses, and depending upon grace.

“Silence means avoiding people.”

Benedictine silence exists for listening, prayer, wise speech, and charity.

“Benedictine balance means an easy life.”

The Rule is moderate but demanding. It requires obedience, self-renunciation, perseverance, discipline, and common life.

“Work is prayer, so formal prayer is unnecessary.”

Work can be offered to God, but it does not replace the Eucharist, liturgical prayer, or personal prayer.

“Lectio divina is a method for receiving private messages.”

It is prayerful reception of Scripture within the faith of the Church, not a technique for producing revelation.

“Laypeople should copy the monastic schedule.”

Lay practice must respect marriage, family, work, health, parish life, and other duties.

“Benedictine peace is mainly an aesthetic.”

Authentic peace grows from right order, grace, worship, justice, forgiveness, and charity.

A Simple Benedictine Rule for Daily Life

The following rule is intended for an ordinary lay Catholic and should be adapted to vocation, health, and responsibilities.

Morning

  • Make the Sign of the Cross.
  • Offer the day to God.
  • Pray a Psalm, Morning Prayer, or a short passage of Scripture.
  • Name the principal duty through which you will serve Christ.

Work

  • Begin with a brief prayer.
  • Work carefully and honestly.
  • Guard against complaint, distraction, and self-display.
  • Pause briefly at midday to recollect yourself before God.

Sacred Reading

  • Spend ten to fifteen minutes with the coming Sunday Gospel.
  • Read slowly.
  • Choose one word or command to carry into action.

Community and Hospitality

  • Listen fully to one person.
  • Accept one interruption with patience.
  • Perform one hidden service.
  • Restrain one unnecessary or harmful comment.

Evening

  • Give thanks for specific graces.
  • Examine stability, obedience, humility, and charity.
  • Make an act of contrition.
  • Pray Night Prayer or another brief closing prayer.

Keep the rule stable for several weeks before adding more.

Signs of Authentic Benedictine Growth

Benedictine spirituality is bearing fruit when the person shows:

  • Greater love for Christ
  • Deeper reverence for the sacred liturgy
  • More faithful prayer
  • Patient attention to Scripture
  • Less dependence on novelty
  • Greater stability in commitments
  • More careful and honest work
  • Restraint in speech
  • Readiness to receive correction
  • Compassion for weakness
  • Greater hospitality
  • Peaceful fidelity to ordinary duties

External Benedictine interests are not sufficient. A person may enjoy chant, monasteries, books, and sacred architecture without becoming more humble or charitable.

The deepest fruit is a heart increasingly able to prefer Christ, listen to His word, and serve Him in others.

Reflection Questions

  1. Do I truly seek God, or mainly religious peace and beauty?
  2. What currently receives first place in the structure of my day?
  3. Does liturgical prayer shape my time?
  4. Am I reading Scripture slowly enough to receive and obey it?
  5. Where do I resist stability or imagine holiness somewhere else?
  6. What aspect of my life most needs continuing conversion?
  7. Do I understand obedience as listening for the sake of Christ?
  8. Does my speech protect or wound community?
  9. How do I receive interruptions, guests, the weak, and the inconvenient?
  10. Is my work ordered, honest, and offered to God?
  11. Have I romanticized monastic life while neglecting my actual vocation?
  12. What small Benedictine practice can I keep faithfully for the next month?

Practical Spiritual Exercise

Listening with the Ear of the Heart

Set aside thirty minutes with Sacred Scripture and a notebook. Choose the Gospel for the coming Sunday.

Lord Jesus Christ, quiet my distractions, soften my self-will, and teach me to listen with the ear of the heart.

1. Read

Read the passage slowly three times. Do not rush to commentary.

2. Listen

Write one word, command, promise, warning, or image that receives your attention.

3. Examine

Ask:

  • What does this reveal about Christ?
  • What in me resists this word?
  • What duty or relationship does it illuminate?

4. Respond

Speak honestly to God in praise, repentance, petition, or thanksgiving.

5. Choose One Act

Select one concrete response for the next twenty-four hours: an apology, a completed duty, a period of silence, an act of hospitality, or a faithful return to prayer.

6. Remain

End with several minutes of quiet attention to God. Do not try to force an experience.

Concluding Prayer

Eternal Father,
Thou hast called Thy children
to seek Thee with undivided hearts.

Lord Jesus Christ,
teach me to prefer nothing to Thee.
Make my prayer faithful,
my work honest,
my service generous,
and my daily duties an offering of love.

Holy Ghost,
open the ear of my heart.
Give me silence to listen,
humility to receive correction,
obedience to follow truth,
and courage to begin again.

Root me in the vocation
Thou hast actually given.
Preserve me from restless escape,
spiritual vanity,
and the search for constant novelty.

Teach me to receive Christ
in Sacred Scripture,
the Holy Eucharist,
the Church,
the guest,
the sick,
the weak,
and those with whom I live.

Through the intercession
of the Blessed Virgin Mary,
St. Benedict,
St. Scholastica,
and all Benedictine saints,
lead me through daily conversion
to the perfect love
that casts out fear.

Amen.

Primary Catholic Sources

Sacred Scripture — Douay-Rheims Bible

  • Psalm 33
  • Psalm 118
  • Matthew 6:25–34
  • Matthew 11:28–30
  • Matthew 25:31–46
  • Luke 10:38–42
  • John 15:1–17
  • Acts 2:42–47
  • Philippians 2:1–16
  • Colossians 3:12–17
  • 1 Thessalonians 5:12–24

The Rule of St. Benedict

  • Prologue: listening, the school of the Lord’s service, perseverance, and the enlargement of the heart
  • Chapter 1: the kinds of monks and the cenobitic life
  • Chapter 3: counsel in the community
  • Chapter 4: the tools of good works
  • Chapter 5: obedience
  • Chapter 6: restraint of speech
  • Chapter 7: humility
  • Chapters 8–20: the Divine Office and reverence in prayer
  • Chapter 31: stewardship
  • Chapters 36–37: care for the sick, elderly, and young
  • Chapter 43: nothing preferred to the Work of God
  • Chapter 48: daily manual labor and sacred reading
  • Chapter 53: reception of guests
  • Chapter 58: reception and profession of monks
  • Chapter 64: the abbot and discretion
  • Chapter 72: good zeal and preference for Christ
  • Chapter 73: the Rule as a beginning of the life of perfection

Catechism of the Catholic Church

  • CCC 914–933: Consecrated life
  • CCC 1322–1419: The Holy Eucharist
  • CCC 1174–1178: The Liturgy of the Hours
  • CCC 1803–1845: Virtues, gifts, and fruits
  • CCC 2558–2565: Prayer as covenant and communion
  • CCC 2653–2654: Sacred Scripture as a source of prayer
  • CCC 2697–2724: Vocal prayer, meditation, and contemplation

Magisterial and Benedictine Sources

  • St. Gregory the Great, Dialogues, Book II
  • Second Vatican Council, Sacrosanctum Concilium
  • Second Vatican Council, Perfectae Caritatis
  • St. Paul VI, Pacis Nuntius
  • St. John Paul II, Vita Consecrata
  • Benedict XVI, General Audience on St. Benedict of Nursia, 9 April 2008
  • Benedict XVI, Verbum Domini, especially nos. 83 and 86–87